Wednesday, March 9, 2011

Essay Workshop 2

“I am very proud of you, Michelle.” Those words echo through my mind even though they were said to me by my father six years ago. It was an amazing day for me. My father was holding my daughter for the first time just a day after she was born. It took 17 years of my life for him to finally say those words to me. Just like Sarah Vowell in “Shooting Dad”, my father and I did not have a very close relationship until I got older and matured.
My father and I were very different people when I was growing up. He was a computer programmer. He would spend hours a day developing new programs for his computer and playing games that I thought were stupid and confused me. He would spend hours cooped up in his tiny little office in our house. I remember thinking that he was insane for staying in that room from the time that he got home from work until dinnertime. After dinner he would go right back in that room and continue working on his complicated projects.
I was a little girl with lots of energy. I could not understand how anybody could sit in a little tiny room with barely any light and no noise except for the tapping of the keys as he hit them and the clicking of the mouse. I wanted to spend all of my time running around in the park that was down the street from my house. Soccer and gymnastics also helped me run off energy so that I could focus on my homework later in the day.
Soccer was a major part of our family. My sister played on a travel soccer team, and after she got into high school, she played on her school team. Almost every weekend from August until October she would have a soccer tournament that we would have to drive to. We would spend the whole weekend there. When I was younger I did not mind being dragged to these tournaments, but eventually I started to loathe them. They took away my time to play with my friends and do whatever I wanted to do. I also did not get a lot of attention during these tournaments because my parents were so focused on the games that my sister was playing in. I remember being able to just run around the parks that the tournaments were held in with no parent supervision.
I also partook in soccer. To my dad though, it was not good enough for him. I did not play on a travel team or my high school team. I attended the travel team tryouts, but my heart was not in it so I never made the team. I did not like travel teams because I did not play soccer for the competition, but for the fun of being able to run around and kick the soccer ball. This lack of interest in competitive soccer seemed to anger my father.
During my soccer games for the local recreational league my dad would yell at me throughout the entire game that I was not trying hard enough or was doing the play wrong. Eventually I stopped enjoying my father being at my games. I dreaded the games that my father would be there. There were even times that I had to skip my own games to attend my sister's tournaments. This made me very irritated.
When I was in ninth grade my father started getting displeased with the fact that I was not yet on a competitive team. He ended up giving me an ultimatum. If I did not make either a travel team or my high school's team I would no longer be able to play soccer. This infuriated me immensely. Why couldn't my father understand that I played for the fun of the game and not for the competition? Per my father's request I attended the tryouts for both the local travel team and my high school team. I believe that because my heart was not fully into the tryouts I did not make the teams. My dad held true to the word of his ultimatum. My parents stopped paying for me to play on the local recreational team, so I stopped playing soccer.
After being forced to stop playing a sport that brought me so much enjoyment when I was on the soccer field, my relationship with my father suffered a great deal. I was extremely angry with him for taking away my ability to participate in a sport that was one of my greatest passions. I started to rebel against him. I stopped listening to what he told me. Instead, I did the complete opposite of what he told me to do. Back talking to him became a daily activity for me. I guess in my mind I decided that since he made me miserable by taking soccer away from me, I would make him miserable.
These behaviors of mine lasted probably about 3 years until I became pregnant with my first daughter and went to a rehabilitation center. During my treatment at the center I matured a lot. I learned to forgive people that may have hurt me and make amends to those that I may have hurt. On my first visit to my parents house I decided to have a talk with my dad. In this talk I apologized to him for my past actions. I explained to him that his decision to take soccer away from me angered me, and that anger caused me to act out against him.
My father acknowledged that he was wrong to try to force me into competitive soccer just because my sister was into it. He apologized for not realizing how much playing soccer meant to me. On this visit my dad took me out to the movies and to dinner. We started to mend our relationship after years of rough times. Every time that I came to visit their house, or my parents came to visit me in the rehabilitation center, my dad would take me out to do something special with just him. During this father-daughter time we would have long talks about things that we enjoyed. We came to realize that we had quite a bit in common.
The next time I saw my father was when my daughter was born. They drove down the day after she was born. We spent several hours together as a family, my mom, my dad, and me. At some point my mother left my dad and I alone in the hospital room. My dad was holding his first granddaughter. He looked over at me and told me that I did a good job bringing her into the world. He then told me that he admired me for not letting the fact that I was having a child at 17 get in the way of graduating high school a year before I was supposed to. He also told me that he was very happy that I started attending classes at the local junior college despite the fact that I was having my baby two weeks into the semester.
“I am very proud of you, Michelle.” I waited 17 years to hear those words come out of my father's mouth. When they finally did an overwhelming feeling of happiness and joy washed through my entire body. It took 17 years, but my father and I finally had a meaningful and close relationship. I think that Sarah kind of felt this way the day that she shot the cannon with her father. I believe that when Sarah had asked to go with her father to shoot the cannon he felt a sense of pride. Just like my dad did when I graduated high school and was attending junior college at 17 with a new baby.

3 comments:

  1. hello, What’s strong about the essay? You essay is already strong, you provide enough to make me understand your situation. What other suggestions or feedback do you want to provide the writer? My suggestion would be, You wrote a lot actually, maybe there's another way to make the essay seem organized and structured. You should take out things that seem unimportant and revise them. Some of the things mention were repetitive. It would be nice, if you mentioned a quote the story you can relate to.

    I did enjoy reading this though, and am sorry for the way your father treated you. He did realized it at the end and said something that made your heart feel warmth!

    Thank You, Lesley

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey
    What is strong about this essay?
    It shows enough information and points to show how you connect with the character. I think that this was well written and you gave me a clear understanding of your points. I have a few suggestions though. I think that it needs to be more structured. Its a bit all over the place. Its nice to know you had such a good relationship with your father when your baby was born. It must have been so great to hear he was so proud of you.
    Thanks! -Catherine

    ReplyDelete
  3. 1.What is the writer�s thesis?  Can you find the statement?  Is it the main point the rest of the essay works to develop?  Yes, the thesis of Michelle's paper was clear and I found the thesis easily in her essay regarding the last sentence of the essay: “Just like Sarah Vowell in “Shooting Dad” my father and I did not have a very close relationship until I got older and matured.” and the last paragraph: “I am very proud of you, Michelle.” Those words echo through my mind even though they were said to me by my father six years ago. It was an amazing day for me. My father was holding my daughter for the first time just a day after she was born.”
    This is also what is developed in making the point of the rest of the essay which is done very well and clearly and concisely understandable.
    2.What evidence is cited to prove and support the writer�s thesis? What pieces of evidence are cited from the readings and/or the writer�s observations to support the thesis?
    The following statements I took from Michelle's essay to support her thesis.
    “My father and I were very different people when I was growing up.”
    “I also did not get a lot of attention because my parents were so focused on the games that my sister was playing in.
    “I also partook in soccer. To my dad though, it was not good enough for him.”
    “When I was in ninth grade my father started getting displeased with the fact that I was not yet on a competitive team.”
    “I guess in my mind I decided that since he made me miserable by taking soccer away from me, I would make him miserable.
    3.Is the writer�s reasoning/critical thinking provided to explain how the evidence proves and supports the thesis?
    Absolutely, I felt she did a nice job I enjoyed the way she put her story together with clear ideas of her strained relationship with her father...she kept my attention of interest in how her life was similar to Sarah's in “Shooting Dad”
    4.What else could the writer cite as evidence in this essay? Michelle, could have included why she thought her relationship changed toward the better with her father when she had her daughter.
    Father daughter relationships are of great importance and as I am the daugther of a strained relationship with my Dad,A father may feel his relationship with his daughter becoming distant as she grows older and it is his chance to allow their relationship to grow and change and to remind himself the teachings he has given to her.
    6.What�s strong about the essay? 
    The last statement of the essay ties to the thesis and the point of the essay and that is:
    “I think that Sarah kind of felt this way the day that she shot the cannon with her father. I believe that when Sarah had asked to go with her father to shoot the cannon he felt a sense of pride. Just like my dad did when I graduated high school and was attending junior college at 17 with a new baby.”
    7.What other suggestions or feedback do you want to provide the writer? I really enjoyed the development of your story I would like to share a few things my mom told me of my father:
    I was always told by my mother, “Learn how to get along with your father and brother, and you'll know how to get along with your husband". I never fully understood her message until years later when I got married and set up housekeeping with my husband. It was then that I learned about compromise, commitment and consideration.”
    lastly, I believe that: “Fathers play an essential role in their daughter's lives. Many things are learned and many things are taught. Some of the most meaningful moments in a daughter's life are spent with her father.
    Also: “When a father takes his responsibility as a guide to his daughter future knowing fully well that this will have an impact on his daughter's life he becomes a co participant in creating a better future for his daughter.”
    Michelle it is also a blessing to capture a relationship with your Dad before it is too late!! I am glad you have!! Thanks Daye

    ReplyDelete